Settling Student Loans Is Not a “Get Out of Debt Free” Pass.” What You Need to Know

Under CARES Act federal student debt freeze has been extended until May 1, 2022, but despite the additional time to prepare, many borrowers may still find it challenging to begin payments. Before the federal loan moratorium went into force, 18% of student loan debtors were falling behind on their payments, based on the Federal Reserve. In addition, before the most recent extension was announced, the Student Debt Crisis Center (SDCC) studied full-time working student loan debtors. Almost one in five stated they would never be financially comfortable to begin payments.

It could be feasible to pay your student debt for less than what you owe if you’re one of the people in danger of delinquency or default. Settlements do occur, although they are uncommon. Additionally, a student debt settlement might not be as advantageous as you think. Below are what you should know about student loan payments and your other choices for handling your student debt.

Student Loans and its settlements nature

In a student loan settlement, you bargain with your lender for a lump sum payment that is less than what you now owe to pay off all your outstanding loans and interest, late fees, and collection costs. If your lender accepts after you complete the payment, the loan is considered fulfilled, and you are released from further repayment obligations. Betsy Mayotte, the CEO and president of The Institute of Student Debt Advisors, advises students about the appeal of student loan settlements. According to her, “most borrowers should anticipate repaying their debts in full as agreed upon when they accepted the promissory note.” Ultimately, the only legitimate reason a lender may settle is if it might be more costly to pursue litigation than an actual settlement.

According to Adam Minsky, a student loan law specialist and National Consumer Law Center contributor, settlements can provide a good result—but only in very narrow circumstances. According to Minsky, only debtors who default on their student loans are typically eligible to negotiate a settlement. And a bankruptcy might have severe adverse effects on both the borrower and any cosigners. The first stage in paying off your student loans is to default, which is a significant decision that should include a debt settlement attorney. Because federal student loan servicers potentially have the right to seize your earnings and confiscate your tax refund to make up for your nonpayment, default is seen as a last choice. With private loans, lenders also have the legal authority to file a lawsuit against you to collect unpaid sums. Private and federal lenders will, at the very least, report your account to the credit bureaus and send it to collections, lowering your credit score.

In more detail, let’s examine the specifics of the government and private student loan settlements.

Fed Students Loan Settlements

Settlements for federal student loans are divided into two categories: regular and discretionary. As a result, your possible terms will vary depending on the kind of settlement you’re qualified for.
Principal and Interest: Only your collection charges are exempt from payment under this settlement.

If you qualify for this type of settlement, the collection expenses and fees will be waived, and you will only be required to pay half of the interest accumulated. Principal + 50% Interest
90% (Principle + Interest): Under this settlement agreement, all collection charges are waived in exchange for your payment of 90% of the principal and interest sum.

Discretionary: You may be eligible for a discretionary settlement if you have severe financial difficulties and cannot pay the other settlement choices. However, the Department of Education must approve the discretionary settlement plan before your loan servicer can submit it.

Private Student Loans Settlements

Personal loans are not subject to the same uniform standards as federal loans since they are issued by financial institutions and internet lenders rather than the government. According to Minsky, “Government student loan repayments are subject to federal rules and regulations, which impose limits and restrictions on those settlements.” Private student loans tend to be more flexible. However, this can differ significantly depending on the particular lender.

Your lender determines how settlements are processed and how much you may settle for. According to Minsky, “student loan settlements can vary significantly based on the kind of student loan, the lender, the applicant’s mitigating circumstances, and whether the applicant has any legitimate legal defenses or arguments.” Therefore, there is no standard percentage figure for student loan settlements.

How to negotiate a settlement

You can begin the student loan procedure by negotiating with your bank on your own, with the assistance of a debt counselor, or with legal representation. In situations of bankruptcy, severe legal challenges, or if there’s a risk the debt could be past the loan’s statute of limitations for collection, says Mayotte, borrowers should speak with a lawyer specializing in student loans. After seeking advice from a lawyer, debt counselor, or tax expert, you can begin the settlement procedure by doing the following:

Collect Evidence:The lender or loan servicer will often want evidence of your inability to repay the debt when you contact them. Therefore, you will be required to provide proof of your financial difficulties, such as current pay stubs, recent tax returns, or evidence of recurring expenses like daycare or medical bills.

Save some cash:You must make a single, large cash payment to clear your debt. The amount needed might be significant; for instance, federal loans may only waive the fees associated with the collection, and you’ll still be responsible for paying the whole principal and interest balance.

Review the Standard Settlement Practices:It’s a good idea to examine the potential settlement before starting discussions. Before speaking with your lender, ensure you’re okay with the conditions since appropriate payments for federal loans, for instance, must adhere to stringent rules. Every model is unique, according to Mayotte. Some borrowers have had luck paying 50 cents on the dollar or less for private loans.

Inquire with the loan holder:Get in touch with the person who has your loan. That could occasionally be your lender or loan servicer. You would have to bargain with the collection agency as your account may have been sold to one if you went into default. Describe your situation and make a lump-sum offer to pay off the debt.

Get the Written Agreement:If your loan holder accepts your proposal to pay off your student loans, be sure to obtain a written agreement explaining the conditions. In addition, get formal evidence that the loan has been paid off after you make the payment to settle the debt so that you are free from further payment obligations.

Drawbacks
Although it may seem fantastic to settle your student loans for less than you owe, there are several significant disadvantages to take into account.

Typically, you have to be in default to pay your student loans. That indicates that you are at least 270 days late on your payments for federal loans. It often involves falling behind on private loans by at least 120 days. However, the precise time frame may differ depending on the lender. Missing so many payments will seriously lower your credit score, discouraging other creditors from doing business with you. Your credit report will no longer reflect the default if you successfully repay the debts. The account will yet appear as a paid debt. Settled accounts show that you made partial payments and are reported to the credit bureaus for seven years. Getting approved for other types of credit could be challenging if you have a credit record settlement.

If you pay your debt, you could have to pay taxes on the amount discharged since the IRS considers the amount waived as income. You must record the discharged amount on your tax return and pay the taxes if the amount is greater than $600. The loan holder will give you a 1099 form.

There is no assurance that your loan holder will accept your settlement offer, even if you provide them with a strong case. Remember that the promissory note the borrower signed binds them legally and that a lender is not required to accept a settlement and may instead decide to go to court to recover their money, advises Mayotte. Since the authorities can seize the borrower’s salary without a court order, federal loans may be more difficult to repay than private loans. Private lenders often have fewer instruments to collect the loan and frequently rely on legal action.